It’s a tough reality of the N.F.L. that quarterbacks get harm. And meaning groups that will have seemed like Super Bowl contenders on paper are all of the sudden sending out Joe Ordinary to take snaps. In different locations, offensive saviors have fallen in need of franchise expectations and been swapped out for well-traveled arms.
Several groups have made quarterback modifications this season, each voluntarily and involuntarily, with drastically completely different outcomes. Here’s a have a look at how these backups have accomplished.
Teddy Bridgewater, New Orleans Saints (5-Zero as a starter)
He was taking up for a legend, Drew Brees, however Bridgewater has been as much as the duty, reeling off 5 consecutive wins. He has 9 touchdowns in opposition to two interceptions, and with the staff two and a half video games away from Carolina within the N.F.C. South, Saints followers have little to complain about.
His finest recreation statistically was a four-touchdown, 314-yard effort in opposition to the Buccaneers in Week 5, however he gave a disciplined effort in a cushty win on Sunday in Chicago with out Alvin Kamara at hand off to.
Brees is hoping to return from thumb surgical procedure sooner moderately than later, however Bridgewater’s performances have not less than given his restoration some respiration room.
Kyle Allen, Carolina Panthers (Four-Zero)
After Cam Newton sprained his foot in Week 2, the Panthers turned to Allen, their second-year man. He did nicely in two appearances final 12 months and has created extra buzz this season, throwing seven touchdowns in 4 wins with out being intercepted.
Newton will regain the beginning job when he returns, maybe in a couple of weeks, however Allen is not less than making it a debate, one thing few would have anticipated when the season began.
Jacoby Brissett, Indianapolis Colts (Four-2)
It was a tall order to interchange Andrew Luck, who shockingly announced his retirement in August, just two weeks before the start of the regular season. But Brissett has been explosive, with 14 touchdowns, one off the league lead, against three interceptions, a clear improvement over his 13 touchdowns and seven interceptions in 2017, when he subbed for an injured Luck. He was exceptional on Sunday, with four touchdown passes, to beat the Texans and take a half-game lead in the A.F.C. South on a day when the team’s running game stalled.
Ryan Tannehill, Tennessee Titans (1-0)
In midgame last week, the Titans sent Marcus Mariota to the bench and turned to the veteran Tannehill, who was most recently a starter with the Dolphins last season. The move has looked inspired so far: Tannehill was 13 of 16 against the Broncos last week and 23 of 29 in a start against the Chargers on Sunday. He has played only a game and a half, but his adjusted yards per pass figure is 9.0, trailing only Patrick Mahomes, Kirk Cousins and Russell Wilson this season.
Gardner Minshew, Jacksonville Jaguars (3-3)
The Jaguars acquired Nick Foles in the off-season, only to see him go down with a broken collarbone in Week 1. That put the team in the hands of Minshew, a little-known rookie who was drafted in the sixth round.
With 10 touchdowns in seven games, two interceptions and an 8.0 adjusted yards per pass figure, Minshew has been more than acceptable. And his mustache and dress sense have made him a cult hero.
Foles is about ready to come back to practice and can play again on Nov. 17 when he comes off injured reserve. It says something about Minshew’s play that there is debate over which quarterback gives the team the better shot to win.
Up and Down
Mason Rudolph, Pittsburgh Steelers (1-2)
Rudolph took over the team when Ben Roethlisberger was lost for the season in Week 2. He was workmanlike, but no Big Ben.
Then he, too, got hurt. His replacement, Devlin Hodges (1-0), had a good completion rate in his one start, but now that Rudolph is out of concussion protocol, he will get another chance next Monday against the Dolphins, a cushy spot for a return.
Chase Daniel, Chicago Bears (0-1)
He filled in when Mitchell Trubisky was hurt and was a combined 44 of 60 with three touchdowns and two interceptions when substituting in against Minnesota and starting versus Oakland. Bears fans weren’t high on Trubisky before, but they welcomed him back readily this week.
Matt Moore, Kansas City Chiefs (0-0)
Not much of a sample size. Moore was 10 of 19 on Thursday against Denver after Patrick Mahomes went down during the game with a dislocated knee.
Moore has been around the N.F.L. since 2007, picking up the odd start here and there. His longest string as a starter came in 2011 with the Dolphins, when he managed a 6-6 record with a pretty poor team. Still, he has only five career starts since then.
Now that Mahomes is out for an indefinite period, we will find out what the 35-year-old Moore has left, starting with a game against the Packers on Sunday night. Quarterback Kyle Shurmur, son of Giants Coach Pat Shurmur, is expected to be promoted from the Chiefs’ practice squad.
Daniel Jones, Giants (2-3)
Giants fans who have embraced the rookie, stepping in for a benched Eli Manning, may dispute this rating. But Jones has seven interceptions against six touchdowns and a poor 5.4 adjusted yards per attempt figure. The promise is there, but after three consecutive losses, the same Giants fans who booed him when he was drafted may be ready to turn on him again.
The Busts (So Far)
Josh Rosen, Miami Dolphins (0-3)
The Dolphins have been switching between Rosen and the opening-day starter, Ryan Fitzpatrick, with dizzying speed. Neither one has been good, but it would defy the ghost of Red Grange for either quarterback to succeed with the motley collection of talent in Miami.
Luke Falk, Jets (0-2)
Sam Darnold got mono, then Trevor Siemian got hurt, making Luke Falk the unlikely starter. He had a decent debut, then was terrible in two starts, going 27 of 48 with three interceptions and no touchdowns. To the relief of Jets fans, Darnold is now back under center.
Colt McCoy, Washington Redskins (0-1)
Now in his sixth year in D.C., and a favorite of Coach Jay Gruden, McCoy was called to sub for the starter Case Keenum for a Week 5 game. The move was a puzzling one, given that the rookie Dwayne Haskins, the supposed future of the franchise, was available.
Unfortunately for McCoy, his shot came against the Patriots. He was 18 of 27 for 122 yards with an interception. Gruden was fired, and McCoy returned to the bench.
McCoy wound up with an adjusted yards per passing figure of 2.9, the lowest in the league for a quarterback with 20 or more passes.