The ban additionally marks an evolution for Mr. Cuomo, a third-term Democrat, who in 2017 signed a invoice that successfully killed a New York City regulation that might have imposed a 5-cent payment on plastic baggage. The New York City payment had additionally been opposed by some in the State Assembly, which has been dominated by Democrats, who nervous that the payment would act as a regressive tax on poor shoppers.
As outlined, nonetheless, the plan to permit counties to keep away from charges on paper baggage would seemingly deal with these considerations. But that provision additionally left some environmental advocates disenchanted; they argue that by not mandating a paper-bag payment, many individuals will merely use paper baggage as a substitute of reusable baggage.
Peter Iwanowicz, the manager director of Environmental Advocates of New York, mentioned the availability to make paper-bag charges non-obligatory made the proposed plan “a weak response to the scourge of disposable bags.”
“New York had a chance to show real leadership and came up short,” he mentioned.
The settlement was additionally being criticized by enterprise and commerce teams, together with the Food Industry Alliance of New York State, which represents grocery shops, a significant goal of such bans and charges.
Mike Durant, the group’s president, mentioned the proposed regulation would “have a drastic impact on retailers,” and predicted confusion due to the opt-in provision. Mr. Durant additionally criticized the allocation of paper-bag payment income to the environmental and bag funds.
“The failure to give even a portion of the 5-cent fee back to the stores, makes this an untenable mandate for many of our members who operate within finite profit margins,” mentioned Mr. Durant. He added, “We are disappointed that the Legislature did not consider this alternative and failed to hear the concerns of the business community.”
Small enterprise teams additionally expressed concern. “Every mandated cost increase adds up,” mentioned Greg Biryla, the New York director of National Federation of Independent Business. “Independent businesses are simply not able to absorb and adjust to new mandated costs the same as their big-box competitors.”